I feel a strange kinship with Michael Moore. They’re trying to pit us against each other in the press, but it’s a hologram. They really have got nothing to do with one another. It’s just some kind of device, some kind of left-right. He makes some salient points. There was some very expert, elliptical editing going on. However, what the hell are we doing in Iraq? No one can explain to me in a reasonable manner that I can accept why we’re there, why we went there, and why we’re still there.
The fear mongering we depict in this film reminds me a little of President Bush and his guys.
I doubt very highly if, while reading the above quotes, you attributed them to Mel Gibson. Jeez I get up to some strange shit at night. Somehow at 1am I started watching Braveheart and then I went down the rabbit hole of IMDB. I think Mel Gibson is an interesting figure because if you like his films, as I do, it brings up many interesting questions. Should we separate the art from the artist? Do we have the right to judge people’s whole lives on possibly momentary lapses of reason? Aren’t people almost always more complex than our media portrays them? I have defended him here before and these quotes again made me remember why I have.
Mel Gibson is someone that struggles from alcoholism and bi-polar disorder. Having known people with both, I know that especially with alcoholism that people that are good and decent in most of their lives can turn into absolute monsters. Most of us would say that alcoholism is a disease and that we should realize the good in people that are struggling against that disease and not condemn them completely for the monster that they may become.
I again am not supporting in anyway the awful things that Gibson has said. He also has displayed extreme hubris by doing things like building a personal chapel on his own property. Any of you that read this blog on a regular basis know that I believe in equality for all and also have politics that at times differ greatly from some of the things that Gibson has professed to. However, what I do defend is his right to make art. Whatever laws he has broken he has paid for. I also read last night that after his drunk driving episode he was on probation for over four years where for several months he had to take classes four times a week.
If you look at our criminal justice system it punishes people long after they have served their debt to society. Many poor people have trouble finding work after serving time or after receiving something like a DUI. Someone like Gibson has the money that they don’t have to worry about those kinds of consequences. He never has to work another day in his life if he wants to. However, we have to be even handed in our justice system. We should prosecute bankers that commit fraud just as we prosecute low level conmen. Inversely if we are going to forgive low income offenders after they have paid their debt to society, which we do not but should, then we should also forgive someone like Gibson once they have paid theirs.
Also, I believe that one should try to separate art from the artist. I am sure all of us own albums or watch movies that have saved our lives at certain times, where if we knew the personal behavior of their creators, might sicken us. I remember hearing a priest one time on the radio talking about how art is often a thing created by people trying to heal themselves from their personal demons. Because of that it is often an altruistic force that should be allowed to stand apart from its creator much of the time. Therefore we should rightly condemn the anti-Semitism of someone like Wagner, but we also should not prevent ourselves from enjoying the extreme beauty of his music.
There is also a portion of our culture that is truly sick that capitalizes on the struggles of others. On the high end this is represented by something like TMZ. On the low end this is represented by something like Busted Magazine or any number of low level publications that print mug photos of our fellow citizens. They capture people at their lowest and weakest moments and make sport of it for the rest of us.
People are complicated. The world is complicated. We live in a society that often values simplicity whether represented as left vs. right or good vs. evil. There are times when we must make hard value judgments that come down on one side or the other of this divide. However, when the world allows it, we should allow our feelings and interpretations of what we see to be, well, complex.